Hello dear
Welcome To Anthony's Pizza - Belmar
Welcome to Anthony's Pizza - Belmar, a beloved culinary gem nestled in the heart of Belmar, NJ. Known for its remarkable selection of pizzas—from the classic cheese to innovative specialty varieties like Buffalo Mac and Cheese and Chicken Scampi—this pizzeria excels in delivering exceptional flavors. The inviting atmosphere, complemented by a friendly staff, creates a warm, family-oriented dining experience. Customers rave about not just the delicious pizza but also the standout dishes like the Shrimp Cocktail and freshly made Cannoli. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or enjoying a meal with family, Anthony's Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers and locals alike.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Cheese Pizza
Sicilian Cheese Pizza
Anchovies Pizza
Sicilian Special Pizza
Cheese Pizza Slice
US$2.00Anchovies Pizza Slice
US$2.00
Mussels Marinara
US$9.45Mozzarella Sticks
Shrimp Cocktail
About
Anthony's Pizza - Belmar
Welcome to Anthony's Pizza - Belmar, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Belmar, New Jersey. Located at 2510 Belmar Blvd K-12, this vibrant pizzeria has become a cherished destination for both locals and visitors alike. With a phone call away at +1 732-681-7211, you can easily place an order to satisfy those pizza cravings.
At Anthony's, the menu is a delightful mix of classic offerings and a creative twist on traditional favorites. Whether you’re indulging in a Classic Cheese Pizza or taking a leap into the adventurous territory of their Specialty Pizzas—like the renowned Anchovies Pizza or the Sicilian Special Pizza—every bite is a celebration of flavor. The buzz around their unique creations, such as the Buffalo Mac and Cheese pizza or Chicken Scampi Pie, showcases their innovative spirit while satisfying the appetites of all types of foodies.
The ambiance at Anthony's Pizza - Belmar feels like a warm embrace, with a family-like environment permeating the space. As one of their loyal patrons, Christine Rusin, so eloquently stated, “the entire staff is just incredible!” It's this sense of community that keeps customers like Jade Cahill coming back for decades—her family has made Anthony's an integral part of their lives, especially after dance classes!
But pizza is only the beginning. Anthony's also offers a tantalizing selection of cold appetizers, including Shrimp Cocktail and Cold Antipasto, perfect for sharing or simply as a tasty start to your meal. Complement your dining experience with one of their tempting cannoli desserts, frequently praised as a highlight of the menu, leaving diners thoroughly satisfied.
In a world filled with pizza joints, Anthony's Pizza - Belmar stands out for its remarkable combination of quality, creativity, and community spirit. Whether you’re grabbing a slice to-go or dining in with family, each visit promises a delightful culinary adventure that keeps people coming back for more. Come experience the magic of Anthony’s, where every meal is crafted with care and served with a smile.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Anthony’s is our go-to place for pizza! I can’t say enough good things about them...Not only is their food amazing but the entire staff is just incredible! Our faves include the Buffalo Mac and cheese pizza, chicken Caesar salad pizza, chicken scampi pie and the street corn pizza (get a slice if you see it!) and of course the sandwiches on garlic rolls and the Anthony’s salad. Make sure you grab at least one zeppoli too! ”
“ Been eating here 20 years before I was married & had my child...to say I'm a loyal, dedicated customer is the very least :). My family would be lost w/out Anthony's! Esp after dance ;) ”
“ Going to be honest, haven’t had the pizza(looks amazing).I come from out of town for work and the food is impeccable! The sauce is so sweet for pasta dishes, pasta fagoili is amazing! Atmosphere is a small family like environment! All the workers are so nice and pleasant! Quick service too for dine in! To wrap it off, tried a cannoli, it’s one of the best I’ve ever had! ”
“ I live in Plont Pleasant with 20 Pizza joints. Anthony's has great specialty slices. Sicilian is great along with the others. ”
“ Great pizza, been there several times. My favorite is the mac and cheese pizza with bacon and meatbal and the Anthony's special is quite good also.. Incredible selection of pizza to choose from. One of my favorite spots when I'm in the area. ”
“ Fun story. My wife (then bride) picked up our wedding cake next door at the Chocolate Carousel. She walked past a nearby pizzeria, desperately wanting a slice, but time was against her. Unfortunately, she could not remember the name of the restaurant. Two days later as we headed home, she mentioned wanting pizza. I searched for one along our route and chose Anthony's. As we drove into the strip mall, her excitement grew when she recognized Anthony's as the pizzeria from the other day. The pizza was delicious!! The staff were excellent and friendly!! They kindly also gave us zeppole as a "wedding gift." You know a restaurant is great when, as you're eating there, you're thinking about coming back for more. That's Anthony's! ”
“ We always get a great meal. This time we tried the Sicilian pizza. It was huge! You certainly get your money's worth at Anthony's. ”
“ Anthony’s Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers. The crust is perfectly crispy yet chewy, and the fresh toppings—especially the mozzarella and vibrant tomato sauce—make each bite delicious. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly and attentive. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, you can’t go wrong here. Highly recommended! ”